# Smash Up: What Were We Thinking?

Smash Up: What Were We Thinking? is a board game for 2–4 players. It plays in 45 minutes and is meant for ages 14 and up. Ludoya players call it best with 3. It is rated 9 out of 10 by 1 Ludoya reviewers. The cheapest copy in stock is $19.99 (United States).

- **Players:** 2–4 (best with 3)
- **Playing time:** 45 minutes
- **Minimum age:** 14+
- **Complexity:** 2.3 out of 5
- **Year published:** 2017
- **Categories:** Fantasy, Humor, Card Game
- **Mechanics:** Card Play Conflict Resolution, Open Drafting, Variable Player Powers, Hand Management, Take That, Area Majority / Influence, Deck Construction, Variable Set-up
- **Ludoya rating:** 9 out of 10, from 1 reviews
- **Owned by:** 10 Ludoya players

**Designers:** Paul Peterson

## Where to buy in United States

| Shop | Price | Link |
| --- | --- | --- |
| Cardhaus Games | 19.99 $ | https://www.cardhaus.com/smash-up-what-were-we-thinking/ |
| Ludifolie | 14.9 € | https://www.ludifolie.com/5528-smash-up-conflit-de-generations.html |
| Hyggeonkel | 179.95 kr | https://www.hyggeonkel.dk/produkt/smash-up-what-were-we-thinking |
| Alphaspel | 299 kr | https://alphaspel.se/491-bradspel/70062-smash-up-what-were-we-thinking |
| Fantasiapelit | 32.5 € | https://www.fantasiapelit.com/index.php?main=ai&kat=single&mista=indeksi&etsittava=_173613 |

## Similar games

- [Smash Up: Cease and Desist](https://www.ludoya.com/games/smash-up-cease-and-desist)
- [Smash Up: That '70s Expansion](https://www.ludoya.com/games/smash-up-that-70s-expansion)
- [Smash Up: Oops, You Did It Again](https://www.ludoya.com/games/smash-up-oops-you-did-it-again)
- [Smash Up: Pretty Pretty Smash Up](https://www.ludoya.com/games/smash-up-pretty-pretty-smash-up)
- [Super Fantasy Brawl](https://www.ludoya.com/games/super-fantasy-brawl)
- [Smash Up: Big in Japan](https://www.ludoya.com/games/smash-up-big-in-japan)
- [Compile: Main 2](https://www.ludoya.com/games/compile-main-2)
- [Smash Up: Disney Edition](https://www.ludoya.com/games/smash-up-disney-edition)
- [Smash Up: Marvel](https://www.ludoya.com/games/smash-up-marvel)
- [Smash Up: Awesome Level 9000](https://www.ludoya.com/games/smash-up-awesome-level-9000)
- [Smash Up: Monster Smash](https://www.ludoya.com/games/smash-up-monster-smash)
- [Smash Up: World Tour – Culture Shock](https://www.ludoya.com/games/smash-up-world-tour-culture-shock)

## Links

- [This page](https://www.ludoya.com/games/smash-up-what-were-we-thinking)
- [Smash Up: What Were We Thinking? in the Ludoya app](https://app.ludoya.com/g/smash-up-what-were-we-thinking)
- [BoardGameGeek entry](https://boardgamegeek.com/boardgame/216658)

_Data from Ludoya, updated 2026-09-19. Ratings, ownership and play counts are Ludoya's own._